e.l.f. Big Mood Mega Volume & Lifting Waterproof Mascara, Bold Volume & Lift, Creates Long-Lasting Voluminous Lashes, Black, 1.1 Oz (10mL)

I've got very sensitive eyes and found this mascara gentle. It's waterproof, yet not too difficult to remove when the time comes. It goes on very subtly but I was able to reapply whilst still wet to build up the lash lengthening effect

Great mascara

I have very sensitive eyes, and finding a mascara that doesn’t irritate them is always a challenge. This one from e.l.f. has been amazing in that respect—no stinging, no watering, and it feels really comfortable to wear all day. The formula gives nice definition and makes my lashes look fuller without clumping too much. The only downside for me is the brush. I find that it tends to hold too much product, which causes it to smudge onto my top eyelid when I apply it. To get around this, I either wipe the excess off on the side of the bottle first, or I use a different clean mascara wand with the product. Once I do that, the results are lovely. Overall, I’d give this 4 stars. The formula itself is fantastic—especially for anyone with sensitive eyes—but the brush design could definitely be improved. Still, it’s a product I’ll happily keep using.

Great mascara, goes on evenly with no smudging.

I was really excited to try this mascara since I’ve relied on waterproof formulas for years, and I was hoping for one that added more volume and length. While it definitely delivered on those aspects, the smudging was a disaster. It was way worse than even regular, non-waterproof mascaras. I was horrified to see huge black smudges under my eyes during work – so embarrassing! Sadly, it’s not the long-lasting waterproof mascara I was expecting.

A great product good price as described well packaged.

This is a strange mascara. The brush is good but it doesn’t feel wet when applying the product to your eyelashes. However once it’s on you can see your wearing mascara. I wouldn’t buy again.

Bit disappointed with this item. It was a replacement for one that had run out. I haven’t found it as good as the original one it was to replace.