
Desertcart purchases this item on your behalf and handles shipping, customs, and support to Colombia.
# 1 NEW YORK TIMES BESTSELLER • “A whirlwind tour of fundamental physics and cosmology.”— The Wall Street Journal “Fascinating . . . a wealth of ideas [that] leave us with a clearer understanding of modern physics in all its invigorating complexity.”— Los Angeles Times When and how did the universe begin? Why are we here? What is the nature of reality? Is the apparent “grand design” of our universe evidence of a benevolent creator who set things in motion—or does science offer another explanation? In The Grand Design , Stephen Hawking and Leonard Mlodinow present the most illuminating scientific thinking about these and other abiding mysteries of the universe, in nontechnical language marked by brilliance and simplicity. According to quantum theory, the cosmos does not have just a single existence or history. The authors explain that we ourselves are the product of quantum fluctuations in the early universe and show how quantum theory predicts the “multiverse”—the idea that ours is just one of many universes that appeared spontaneously out of nothing, each with different laws of nature. They conclude with a riveting assessment of M-theory, an explanation of the laws governing our universe that is currently the only viable candidate for a “theory of everything”: the unified theory that Einstein was looking for, which, if confirmed, would represent the ultimate triumph of human reason. A succinct, startling, and lavishly illustrated guide to discoveries that are altering our understanding and threatening some of our most cherished belief systems, The Grand Design is a book that will inform—and provoke—like no other. Review: Philosophy and cosmology happily meet! - This is a review by a layman grappling with the not so self-evident laws of the incredibly small and large physical realities. I read and very much enjoyed Stephen Hawking's A Brief History of Time and The Universe in a Nutshell although have not come across any of L. Mlodinow's several popular books on physics and quantum physics. This book is very different from the previous two Hawking books and several other readings on cosmology, all of which attempt to familiarize the lay audience with the intricate principles of modern physics, i.e. the theory of general relativity (GR), quantum mechanics (QM), various flavors of string theory complete with M-theory, and multiverses. Here, most of this knowledge is taken for granted at least on an elementary level. The authors focus instead on the philosophical aspects of the immense new knowledge that has been gained since Maxwell's formalization of electro-magnetism and Einstein's concept of space-time fabric. Ancient philosophers, legends of various religious worldviews, and respectful dispute with creationist beliefs make their appearances throughout the engaging narration. On the way to the "theory of everything," that in the writers' opinion seems to be the hard-to-swallow concept of M-theory with its 10 spatial dimensions, we meet a few modern principles of acquiring knowledge. One of them is the "top down approach" which makes conclusions about the past based on the present using probability calculations instead of describing universal history as a linear event with a fixed beginning and predetermined outcome. Another is the "anthropic principle" which uses the very existence of humans as an argument in the interpretation of the Universe. The story we are presented with is an unapologetic utilization of the still poorly understood and even less readily imaginable principles of quantum mechanics. According to this worldview, our very existence is due to nothing else but quantum fluctuation in the primordial Universe, when its size was in the range of the Planck length (length of 10 to the negative 35 meters). In the randomness of temperature variations of multiple (10 to the 500!?) imaginable early universes one had just the right conditions, i.e. temperature differences, to be able to form clumps of material, the birthplace of present day galaxies, following the inflation. In fact the small but well documented temperature variation in the cosmic microwave background radiation is thought to be the thumbprint of this primordial quantum fluctuation. It seems to me that by the time galaxies formed, the laws of GR that apparently govern today's cosmos on a grand scale, overshadowed the principles of QM that dominated the "baby" Universe. Although this "changing of the guards" of the physical laws from QM to GR clearly had to be a continuum, until today even the smartest minds among us have not been able to find a theory that can describe a smooth transition between the two. QM and GR simply do not seem to coexist very well together: using QM laws, the GR equations invariably result in infinite results, the mathematical equivalence of "garbage." The book however ends on a positive note: M-theory. Although M-theory itself, like all other major concepts of physics in this fairly short book, is only briefly presented, the authors leave little doubt about their current conviction that the theory is a major candidate for Einstein's unfulfilled dream, the unified theory. To illustrate what the real meaning of a "unified theory" may be, the authors discuss the Game of Life in full seven pages. The essence of the game is to build various structures based on three simple basic laws. These structures - one may look at them as multiverses - will evolve very differently despite the uniformity of the three rules depending on the initial conditions, i.e. how one places the two building blocks (life or death) on the checkered board at the beginning of the game. In the process, various formations are produced that seem to follow certain rules (think of the laws of thermodynamics, Newton's three laws of motion, etc.) while the underlying three basic rules never change. Of course, M-theory is not without controversies due to the mathematical complexities required to model it and the extremely small size of strings that are thought to be the theory's building blocks. In fact, the energy necessary to dissect matter to the infinitesimal size of strings and thus make them observable seems to be unattainable. Viewed in this way, the difference between a supernatural creator (God) and M-theory seems to be almost negligible at first glimpse. Although the authors don't explicitly get tangled in the emotional battle between spirituality and materialism, they provide sufficient circumstantial evidence in the form of reproducible observational data to make a strong intellectual argument that God is not necessary to answer mankind's ever recurring questions: `Why do we exist? Why is there something rather than nothing?' and the one question for which you have to be a physicist to ask: "Why this particular set of laws and not some other?" The book is a well-narrated, mostly enjoyable read even for a lay person like myself - someone not involved in the field of physics in any way. I think however that without a basic understanding of GR and QM much of the book's main premises will fly over a potential reader's head. The two books by Hawking mentioned at the beginning of this review will certainly be sufficient to appreciate the magical world revealed in The Grand Design: the world of theoretical physics and cosmology hidden from most of us who grew up on Euclidean geometry and Newtonian physics. There were only very few places where I felt a touch of too much technicality - e.g. "renormalization" -, or not sufficient clarity - e.g. brief references to "super symmetry", or the Feynman diagrams. Many of the pictures were intuitive and helpful, although I wish a few of them had more detailed captions - e.g. the figure of Quarks or the Triple Alpha Process. The cartoons were sufficiently witty to contribute to the overall entertaining mood of the book. I would recommend the book to all those interested in cosmology and particle physics, but most of all to those tickled by a natural scientific approach to life's great philosophical questions and the unquenchable thirst of humans to acquire knowledge. Review: A desperate effort to deny the obvious - The Grand Design, while still qualifying an helpful general overview of cosmology for nonscientists, is in its essence, a profoundly unpersuasive book about metaphysics, in which Hawking asks the questions: "Why is there something rather than nothing? "Why do we exist? "Why this particular set of laws and not some other?" but refuses to acknowledge the conclusions which his own summary of the evidence should properly lead him to. Specifically, Hawking's stated goal is to establish that it is at least "possible to answer these questions purely within the realm of science, without invoking any divine beings." What is remarkable in this formulation is its tacit admission that the evidence for a deliberate design of the universe for the purpose of supporting life has become so overwhelming, the best an atheist such as Hawking (per his ex-wife ) may do is merely to try to prevent the case for a kind of intelligent design to be formally declared made. Remarkably, Hawking fails even in this modest ambition. Even if there are persuasive answers to these questions within the realm of science, they do not emerge from this book. The problem for atheists and agnostics is that, as Hawking forthrightly acknowledges, "Our universe and its laws appear to have a design that is both tailor-made to support us and if we are to exist leaves little room for alteration. This is not easily explained, and raises the natural question of why it is that way." The chances of the laws of physics having been randomly set to support life seems so astonishingly small as to be for all practical purposes, zero. As Hawking noted in A Brief History of Time "If the rate of expansion one second after the Big Bang have been smaller by even one part in 100,000 million million, the universe would have re-collapsed before it ever reached its present size." And this is only one of the 6 rules of physics, the precise setting of which were identified by physicist Martin Rees in his book Just Six Numbers: The Deep Forces That Shape The Universe as essential to the existence of life. Nor do these 6 numbers include the very peculiar fact that in order for carbon to exist in any appreciable quantities "the sum of the energies of a beryllium nucleus and a helium nucleus must be almost exactly the energy of a certain quantum state of the isotope of carbon formed, a situation called a resonance, which greatly increases the rate of a nuclear reaction". The odds of this occurring randomly was deemed so small by the man who predicted it that he, Astronomer Fred Hoyle, asserted that "I do not believe that any scientist to examine the evidence would fail to draw the inference that the laws of nuclear physics have been deliberately designed with regard to the consequences they produce inside the stars". The same inference could just as easily be made regarding the fact that so many other laws of nature seem so precisely calibrated to support life. This is an inference however Hawking declines to make, most likely because "Some would claim that the answers to these questions is that there is a God whose chose to create universe that way." Unfortunately for those whose world view is premised upon belief in a random and meaningless universe, Hawking's alternative explanation, as set forth in this book, is completely unpersuasive Briefly, as best I can tell, Hawking's argument boils down invocation of M-Theory and Feynman's multiple-histories theory to suggest that there are innumerable alternative universes with different laws of physics, the vast majority of which do not support life, leaving it no more than a matter of random chance at least one does. However, the fact that M-theory allows for this possibility or that multiple-histories, as applied by Hawking, assumes it, offers little actual reason to believe that such alternative universes really do exist. Hawking observes that "The laws of M-theory ... allow for different universes with different apparent laws, depending on how the internal spaces curled. M-theory has solutions that allow for many different internal spaces, perhaps as many as 10 to the 500th power which allows for ten to the 500th power different universes, each with its own laws." And because the M-Theory allows for this enormous amounts of Universes, therefore apparently such Universes must exist, and it is simply our good fortune to live in one of the few numbers of such Universes that allow for life. The problem with this reasoning is it assumes that because the M-theory "allows" for different universes with different laws, that is reason enough to believe they exist. This is a breathtaking logical leap, something akin to saying because the laws of physics allow for the possibility that aliens are abducting human being and harvesting them for their sperm and eggs to create an alien-human hybrid species, therefore they are. However, the mere fact that something is not impossible is not evidence of its existence. The Constitution allows for any child born in the United States (except for the children of diplomats) to become president after the age of 35. Nevertheless, for me to insist that Yemen-based Islamic cleric Anwar al-Awlaki will eventually become President simply because he was born in the United States (not of diplomats) and is over 35 years old is probably not going to convince many people to contribute to his campaign. Hawking's other argument for the existence of multiple universes is so obviously fallacious that it is remarkable that a man of his extraordinary learning and intelligence could even seriously propose it. He starts off by reasoning from Feynman's multiple histories theories that no quantum event has a single history, but actually a virtual infinity of histories, and the only way to predict the outcome of any particular quantum event is to sum all the possible events which might occur and divide it in some way to come up with the likelihood of any particular outcome. Thus in describing how photons pass through the slits in the screen in the famous "double slit" experiment, one must take into account the possibility that the photon may have circled around Jupiter before arriving it its final destination. Therefore, Hawking argues, that to determine how the Universe got to its present state, one must sum up all the possible different states it could have begun with, including, apparently, those 10 to the 500th power different possible starting states of the Universe allowed by M theory. Therefore, given the fact that we human beings exist, ultimately when one sums up and divides all these alternative histories, one arrives again at the fact that we are fortunate enough to live up in one of the few (or perhaps only) Universe which allows for our existence. The problem is that this argument simply assumes away the question. To use the alien abduction analogy again, its like saying that the double slit experiment demonstrates that there are human-abducting extraterrestrials because in developing the necessary sums to determine the outcome of the experiment one must take into possibility that a photon travelled to the mothership orbiting the earth and passed through a memorandum setting forth their insidious hybrid insemination scheme. In short, for Hawking's version of multiple histories to take into consideration multiple alternative universes, it must assume multiple alternative universes exist. Assumptions are not evidence, a legal principle even physicists should be somewhat acquainted with. At the end of the day, the one point which must be conceded to Hawking and other like Richard Dawkins and Martin Rees who rely upon belief in multiple alternative universes to avoid the otherwise inescapable conclusion that the Universe is designed to support life, is that there is no evidence to conclusively demonstrate that such alternative universes do not exist, just as there is no conclusive evidence that human abducting aliens do not exist either. But actually that's not a fair comparison. There is in fact, at the very least, an immense amount of testimonial evidence of alien abduction. However, there is no evidence at all for the existence of multiple universes merely, as Hawking correctly notes, various (untested) theories which may allow for the possibility of their existence, just as surely as there are in fact far more reliable and tested theories allowing for the possibility of extraterrestrial kidnappers and the future presidency of Imam Al-Awaki. So while Hawking is ultimately correct to assert that it is possible to answer his questions "purely within the realm of science, without invoking any divine beings", it would have been more candid to add that there is no evidence at all to support the suggested possibilities, while the evidence that the law of physics were precisely calibrated to support life is somewhere between enormous and overwhelming. The fact that Hawking feels compelled to raise such unconvincing arguments for refuting the case for the strong anthropic principle as he does in this book is a testimony to just how desperate non-theists have become in their efforts to deny the obvious. Nevertheless, the book is still well worth reading for its entertaining and informative overview of the current state of cosmology.
| Best Sellers Rank | #148,746 in Books ( See Top 100 in Books ) #78 in Cosmology (Books) #82 in Astrophysics & Space Science (Books) |
| Customer Reviews | 4.4 out of 5 stars 4,383 Reviews |
L**P
Philosophy and cosmology happily meet!
This is a review by a layman grappling with the not so self-evident laws of the incredibly small and large physical realities. I read and very much enjoyed Stephen Hawking's A Brief History of Time and The Universe in a Nutshell although have not come across any of L. Mlodinow's several popular books on physics and quantum physics. This book is very different from the previous two Hawking books and several other readings on cosmology, all of which attempt to familiarize the lay audience with the intricate principles of modern physics, i.e. the theory of general relativity (GR), quantum mechanics (QM), various flavors of string theory complete with M-theory, and multiverses. Here, most of this knowledge is taken for granted at least on an elementary level. The authors focus instead on the philosophical aspects of the immense new knowledge that has been gained since Maxwell's formalization of electro-magnetism and Einstein's concept of space-time fabric. Ancient philosophers, legends of various religious worldviews, and respectful dispute with creationist beliefs make their appearances throughout the engaging narration. On the way to the "theory of everything," that in the writers' opinion seems to be the hard-to-swallow concept of M-theory with its 10 spatial dimensions, we meet a few modern principles of acquiring knowledge. One of them is the "top down approach" which makes conclusions about the past based on the present using probability calculations instead of describing universal history as a linear event with a fixed beginning and predetermined outcome. Another is the "anthropic principle" which uses the very existence of humans as an argument in the interpretation of the Universe. The story we are presented with is an unapologetic utilization of the still poorly understood and even less readily imaginable principles of quantum mechanics. According to this worldview, our very existence is due to nothing else but quantum fluctuation in the primordial Universe, when its size was in the range of the Planck length (length of 10 to the negative 35 meters). In the randomness of temperature variations of multiple (10 to the 500!?) imaginable early universes one had just the right conditions, i.e. temperature differences, to be able to form clumps of material, the birthplace of present day galaxies, following the inflation. In fact the small but well documented temperature variation in the cosmic microwave background radiation is thought to be the thumbprint of this primordial quantum fluctuation. It seems to me that by the time galaxies formed, the laws of GR that apparently govern today's cosmos on a grand scale, overshadowed the principles of QM that dominated the "baby" Universe. Although this "changing of the guards" of the physical laws from QM to GR clearly had to be a continuum, until today even the smartest minds among us have not been able to find a theory that can describe a smooth transition between the two. QM and GR simply do not seem to coexist very well together: using QM laws, the GR equations invariably result in infinite results, the mathematical equivalence of "garbage." The book however ends on a positive note: M-theory. Although M-theory itself, like all other major concepts of physics in this fairly short book, is only briefly presented, the authors leave little doubt about their current conviction that the theory is a major candidate for Einstein's unfulfilled dream, the unified theory. To illustrate what the real meaning of a "unified theory" may be, the authors discuss the Game of Life in full seven pages. The essence of the game is to build various structures based on three simple basic laws. These structures - one may look at them as multiverses - will evolve very differently despite the uniformity of the three rules depending on the initial conditions, i.e. how one places the two building blocks (life or death) on the checkered board at the beginning of the game. In the process, various formations are produced that seem to follow certain rules (think of the laws of thermodynamics, Newton's three laws of motion, etc.) while the underlying three basic rules never change. Of course, M-theory is not without controversies due to the mathematical complexities required to model it and the extremely small size of strings that are thought to be the theory's building blocks. In fact, the energy necessary to dissect matter to the infinitesimal size of strings and thus make them observable seems to be unattainable. Viewed in this way, the difference between a supernatural creator (God) and M-theory seems to be almost negligible at first glimpse. Although the authors don't explicitly get tangled in the emotional battle between spirituality and materialism, they provide sufficient circumstantial evidence in the form of reproducible observational data to make a strong intellectual argument that God is not necessary to answer mankind's ever recurring questions: `Why do we exist? Why is there something rather than nothing?' and the one question for which you have to be a physicist to ask: "Why this particular set of laws and not some other?" The book is a well-narrated, mostly enjoyable read even for a lay person like myself - someone not involved in the field of physics in any way. I think however that without a basic understanding of GR and QM much of the book's main premises will fly over a potential reader's head. The two books by Hawking mentioned at the beginning of this review will certainly be sufficient to appreciate the magical world revealed in The Grand Design: the world of theoretical physics and cosmology hidden from most of us who grew up on Euclidean geometry and Newtonian physics. There were only very few places where I felt a touch of too much technicality - e.g. "renormalization" -, or not sufficient clarity - e.g. brief references to "super symmetry", or the Feynman diagrams. Many of the pictures were intuitive and helpful, although I wish a few of them had more detailed captions - e.g. the figure of Quarks or the Triple Alpha Process. The cartoons were sufficiently witty to contribute to the overall entertaining mood of the book. I would recommend the book to all those interested in cosmology and particle physics, but most of all to those tickled by a natural scientific approach to life's great philosophical questions and the unquenchable thirst of humans to acquire knowledge.
M**L
A desperate effort to deny the obvious
The Grand Design, while still qualifying an helpful general overview of cosmology for nonscientists, is in its essence, a profoundly unpersuasive book about metaphysics, in which Hawking asks the questions: "Why is there something rather than nothing? "Why do we exist? "Why this particular set of laws and not some other?" but refuses to acknowledge the conclusions which his own summary of the evidence should properly lead him to. Specifically, Hawking's stated goal is to establish that it is at least "possible to answer these questions purely within the realm of science, without invoking any divine beings." What is remarkable in this formulation is its tacit admission that the evidence for a deliberate design of the universe for the purpose of supporting life has become so overwhelming, the best an atheist such as Hawking (per his ex-wife ) may do is merely to try to prevent the case for a kind of intelligent design to be formally declared made. Remarkably, Hawking fails even in this modest ambition. Even if there are persuasive answers to these questions within the realm of science, they do not emerge from this book. The problem for atheists and agnostics is that, as Hawking forthrightly acknowledges, "Our universe and its laws appear to have a design that is both tailor-made to support us and if we are to exist leaves little room for alteration. This is not easily explained, and raises the natural question of why it is that way." The chances of the laws of physics having been randomly set to support life seems so astonishingly small as to be for all practical purposes, zero. As Hawking noted in A Brief History of Time "If the rate of expansion one second after the Big Bang have been smaller by even one part in 100,000 million million, the universe would have re-collapsed before it ever reached its present size." And this is only one of the 6 rules of physics, the precise setting of which were identified by physicist Martin Rees in his book Just Six Numbers: The Deep Forces That Shape The Universe as essential to the existence of life. Nor do these 6 numbers include the very peculiar fact that in order for carbon to exist in any appreciable quantities "the sum of the energies of a beryllium nucleus and a helium nucleus must be almost exactly the energy of a certain quantum state of the isotope of carbon formed, a situation called a resonance, which greatly increases the rate of a nuclear reaction". The odds of this occurring randomly was deemed so small by the man who predicted it that he, Astronomer Fred Hoyle, asserted that "I do not believe that any scientist to examine the evidence would fail to draw the inference that the laws of nuclear physics have been deliberately designed with regard to the consequences they produce inside the stars". The same inference could just as easily be made regarding the fact that so many other laws of nature seem so precisely calibrated to support life. This is an inference however Hawking declines to make, most likely because "Some would claim that the answers to these questions is that there is a God whose chose to create universe that way." Unfortunately for those whose world view is premised upon belief in a random and meaningless universe, Hawking's alternative explanation, as set forth in this book, is completely unpersuasive Briefly, as best I can tell, Hawking's argument boils down invocation of M-Theory and Feynman's multiple-histories theory to suggest that there are innumerable alternative universes with different laws of physics, the vast majority of which do not support life, leaving it no more than a matter of random chance at least one does. However, the fact that M-theory allows for this possibility or that multiple-histories, as applied by Hawking, assumes it, offers little actual reason to believe that such alternative universes really do exist. Hawking observes that "The laws of M-theory ... allow for different universes with different apparent laws, depending on how the internal spaces curled. M-theory has solutions that allow for many different internal spaces, perhaps as many as 10 to the 500th power which allows for ten to the 500th power different universes, each with its own laws." And because the M-Theory allows for this enormous amounts of Universes, therefore apparently such Universes must exist, and it is simply our good fortune to live in one of the few numbers of such Universes that allow for life. The problem with this reasoning is it assumes that because the M-theory "allows" for different universes with different laws, that is reason enough to believe they exist. This is a breathtaking logical leap, something akin to saying because the laws of physics allow for the possibility that aliens are abducting human being and harvesting them for their sperm and eggs to create an alien-human hybrid species, therefore they are. However, the mere fact that something is not impossible is not evidence of its existence. The Constitution allows for any child born in the United States (except for the children of diplomats) to become president after the age of 35. Nevertheless, for me to insist that Yemen-based Islamic cleric Anwar al-Awlaki will eventually become President simply because he was born in the United States (not of diplomats) and is over 35 years old is probably not going to convince many people to contribute to his campaign. Hawking's other argument for the existence of multiple universes is so obviously fallacious that it is remarkable that a man of his extraordinary learning and intelligence could even seriously propose it. He starts off by reasoning from Feynman's multiple histories theories that no quantum event has a single history, but actually a virtual infinity of histories, and the only way to predict the outcome of any particular quantum event is to sum all the possible events which might occur and divide it in some way to come up with the likelihood of any particular outcome. Thus in describing how photons pass through the slits in the screen in the famous "double slit" experiment, one must take into account the possibility that the photon may have circled around Jupiter before arriving it its final destination. Therefore, Hawking argues, that to determine how the Universe got to its present state, one must sum up all the possible different states it could have begun with, including, apparently, those 10 to the 500th power different possible starting states of the Universe allowed by M theory. Therefore, given the fact that we human beings exist, ultimately when one sums up and divides all these alternative histories, one arrives again at the fact that we are fortunate enough to live up in one of the few (or perhaps only) Universe which allows for our existence. The problem is that this argument simply assumes away the question. To use the alien abduction analogy again, its like saying that the double slit experiment demonstrates that there are human-abducting extraterrestrials because in developing the necessary sums to determine the outcome of the experiment one must take into possibility that a photon travelled to the mothership orbiting the earth and passed through a memorandum setting forth their insidious hybrid insemination scheme. In short, for Hawking's version of multiple histories to take into consideration multiple alternative universes, it must assume multiple alternative universes exist. Assumptions are not evidence, a legal principle even physicists should be somewhat acquainted with. At the end of the day, the one point which must be conceded to Hawking and other like Richard Dawkins and Martin Rees who rely upon belief in multiple alternative universes to avoid the otherwise inescapable conclusion that the Universe is designed to support life, is that there is no evidence to conclusively demonstrate that such alternative universes do not exist, just as there is no conclusive evidence that human abducting aliens do not exist either. But actually that's not a fair comparison. There is in fact, at the very least, an immense amount of testimonial evidence of alien abduction. However, there is no evidence at all for the existence of multiple universes merely, as Hawking correctly notes, various (untested) theories which may allow for the possibility of their existence, just as surely as there are in fact far more reliable and tested theories allowing for the possibility of extraterrestrial kidnappers and the future presidency of Imam Al-Awaki. So while Hawking is ultimately correct to assert that it is possible to answer his questions "purely within the realm of science, without invoking any divine beings", it would have been more candid to add that there is no evidence at all to support the suggested possibilities, while the evidence that the law of physics were precisely calibrated to support life is somewhere between enormous and overwhelming. The fact that Hawking feels compelled to raise such unconvincing arguments for refuting the case for the strong anthropic principle as he does in this book is a testimony to just how desperate non-theists have become in their efforts to deny the obvious. Nevertheless, the book is still well worth reading for its entertaining and informative overview of the current state of cosmology.
J**M
why we are here
If you want to how nature and the universe works, evidence based, this is for you. No math is required. This book provides an understanding that is satisfying.
N**L
For a non-physicist like me, it was a heavenly gift
This was the longest short book I have read as yet. For a non-physicist like me, it was a heavenly gift. Stephen Hawkings has the unique way of explaining to a layman like me what it is all about; where we are and how we got here. It is pure reasoning and logic. No preconceived notions, no premonitions. Some claim that there is no other scientist of equivalent stature between him and Einstein. He tells the story of early thinking human beings and how they questioned the nature of their own being and the universe at large. We as humans have existed for 200,0000 years but learnt to read and write only 7000 years back. The first thinkers were perhaps Ionians (present day Turkey). It deals with the questions early Ionians asked for example, as humans infants cannot take care of themselves, the first humans would not have surfaced as infants. He then argues that as the philosophers have failed to answer the question of life and universe, the scientists have to do their part. The book takes you to a tour de force of subatomic physics and the laws of forces which govern them and how we came to know about it all. There are four major forces in nature, electromagnetic, week nuclear force, strong nuclear force and gravity. It was very gratifying and I felt proud to see the name of Abdus Salam in the book. He is credited with the theory of week nuclear forces.This force is responsible for the radioactivity and plays a vital role in the formation of elements in stars and early universe. He and others theorized that in 1967, were awarded Nobel in 1979. The W and Z particles which he theorized were observed however only in 1983. It is now known that the universe is expanding. It leads to a simple question. Going back, it would have been almost nothing. As more we understand the way the nature works, the less one has to burden the gods and heavenly beings for the work of nature. He, contrary to my preconceived bias of Hawkings, does not make an aggressive attempt to discredit god. He merely makes an argument that spontaneous creation is a possibility. It is a marvellously easy read for the level of complex theoretical physics it teaches you along the way; all the way to the ultimate 11-dimensional M- theory, the candidate theory about everything. Nasir Gondal
T**W
A Science Book with Lots of Humor
If you want to read a science book that has a lot of humor in it, this is a good choice. I feel Stephen Hawking made complex concepts understandable and he also has a knack for explaining history in an interesting way. If you are looking for a book that explains a lot of concepts secular scientists believe, this will interest you. The debate between creationists and secular scientists becomes more clear when you look at both sides of the story. What also makes this book really cute is the use of Sidney Harris' funny cartoons throughout. This book reminded me of a time when I was first enjoying learning about science in the 1900s and my dad explained how light was a particle and a wave. My dad being a bit of a scientist and inventor was helpful when I had to do projects for science class. So some of this book was a trip down memory lane. What I guess I disagree with is that God was not necessary for creation and that philosophy is dead. I think philosophy is very much alive, why else do people start threads at forums discussing what happens after death? I think the question of "Why are we here?" resonates with almost anyone. I did however think that Stephen Hawking is right when he presents his insight into why the world is such a mess. When he is also talking about God possibly creating the universe - I think he is nearer to the truth. But needless to say I enjoyed reading this book and found it entertaining and educational. Just be prepared for words like "geodesics." There is fortunately a glossary in this book. If you read it on the kindle of course, you can have all sorts of fun looking up words. ~The Rebecca Review
R**S
His weekest book.
I just recently finished reading my third Hawking book "The Grand Design", but first about the book itself. It is excellent quality, sturdy, hard-bound. Fortunately there's a lot of room for notes and comments, (I don't think I annotated any book as much as this one. There's a few empty pages between some chapters that are now filled.) Interestingly, many do believe if you give enough monkeys enough time, they could, by chance, type out the works of Shakespeare. With the best of highly educated scientists coupled with (presumptuously) professional proof-readers and finally computer spell checking, he still has at least one type-o in his book. Good quality 4-color pages and very easy on the eyes to read. As for the content, a briefer summary of science and some religious views through-out mankind's history as his "Brief History of Time". An elegant and concise reading on quantum and M theories. I must say most of what is in there I am already very familiar with, but it too, was all laid out very nicely and concisely. Paradoxly, Hawking writing "Philosophy is dead" is a philosophical statement. His seriously questioning whether a table in another room still might be there when you leave, also shows philosophy isn't dead. I'm confident time will easily prove him wrong here. Hawking speculates at the beginning of the big bang multiple universes were formed with varying laws of physics. Our universe is merely one of many that just so happens, by chance, to have these "laws" exactly right for life to occur. Since, now, we have odds for this to happen, we can no longer claim exclusively God created our universe specifically for us. He offers no scientific proof that these laws, (gravity, weak and strong nuclear forces and electromagnetic force) can even be variable, it's a shame he didn't. And as he says, this 'still doesn't prove there is no God', this theory only implies that nature has an astronomically improbable chance to do it on its own, adding even one more to the many astronomically improbable chances in the process of the theory of evolution. Although, now the contrary also becomes an additional consideration; Instead of less need for God, there is now more of a need. Since the odds of having a universe with "perfect" laws now proves to be most increasingly unlikely, there is equally, a need for Someone to make sure at least one of the many innumerable universes has the astronomically unlikely "happenstance" of perfectly balanced, steady and reliable laws. The book is quite short, and proposes or leaves many questions unanswered. Hawking doesn't discuss whether or not it's been scientifically proven that the four forces can vary from anything other than what they are, or whether the Big Bang is a cycle that repeats itself. This would also allow chance opportunities for the perfect universe to blast itself into existence, a theory, I believe, is simply way to preposterous to happen given any number of universes, chances and time. Professor Hawking doesn't propose or calculate any mathematical odds, as even Richard Dawkins and Carl Sagan do. Nor does he explain what it might be like at the "boundaries" where two different universes with different physical laws meet. There certainly has to be "clashing" of some sort. He does show how binary stars couldn't have planets that support life, just as planets that have elliptical orbits. I'm aware that more than half of the stars in our universe are at least binary. Professor Hawking doesn't attempt at what percentage of planets may be too elliptical. These are things worthy to know and that need to be considered, especially when one discusses Drake's equation. Ultimately, other than a handful of "trivia bits" "The Grand Universe" doesn't really offer much new, especially factual, nor as much as his other books have. But it is an interesting summary of what is already out there that most people keeping up with things may already know. The book is a nice package of recent theories all wrapped up in one. Still worth the read, but certainly his weakest book.
S**S
Interested in Understanding Fundamentals of the Universe?
I read The Grand Design in one sitting, it took me a couple of hours. In the past when I've read physics books (for example, A Brief History of Time or The Elegant Universe: Superstrings, Hidden Dimensions, and the Quest for the Ultimate Theory ) it has been necessary for me to pace myself, to slow down and drop the book every now and then to think long and hard about the latest mind-bending lesson I'd just learned about the nature of our universe. This wasn't the case with The Grand Design. The material covered is certainly grand and epic, but the presentation is relatively light. There's no math at all, and the style is welcoming. This book is VERY understandable as far as popular physics goes, and I was extremely impressed at Professor Hawking and Mlodinow's ability to explain fundamentals of the universe in such an approachable way. This book covers some of the history of scientific theory. How did old-school scientists decide how to approach the study of our world? How did we end up framing the universe as a series of laws and theories? How does philosophy fit into this puzzle? The Grand Design moves on to give a primer on quantum physics and then covers such controversial topics as free will, an infinite number of universes, and the view of our own universe as one without a designer/creator. The writing style is clear and concise, with plenty of anecdotes. It's entertaining and interesting, even funny at times. The authors move in such a logical way from one topic to another, building up concepts and knowledge, that by the end you may be surprised at just how comfortable you feel thinking about some of the deepest mysteries of our universe. You probably won't be figuring out the 'theory of everything' any time soon after reading this book, and the model/conclusion presented in this book may not actually shake out to be 100% correct - but if you read The Grand Design then chances are you'll have a much better understanding of the related material than you did yesterday. To me this is a great thing. I read this book on my Kindle. The one thing I should note is that a number of the illustrations have labels such as "the yellow line shows X and the blue line shows Y" - and unfortunately the Kindle is black and white. As a result it can be tough to tell exactly what the authors mean when it comes to the visual supplements. Not really a huge deal, but worth mentioning.
J**T
Stephen Hawking's Theology Revealed in the Grand Design
Stephen Hawking's Theology Revealed in The Grand Design By John H. Calvert The title of Stephen Hawking's latest book, "The Grand Design," implies that the universe arose from an intelligence. But, the message inside is the opposite. For Hawking the apparent design of our universe and of life is an illusion, explained by unguided natural causes. So, he doesn't "need" a Creator to relate our lives to the world. He claims everything just naturally arose out of a quantum event that has no pre-history or antecedent such as God. All that followed was determined by the mindless laws of physics and chemistry that have no author. Even our free will is an illusion. Like an oracle, Hawking is revered as the high priest of modern science. He admits these conclusions seem absurd, for which he blames quantum physics. The absurdity of quantum theory is true for him but unknowable to us. So, what can a lay person make of this "scientific" answer to the ultimate question of life: Where do we come from? Should we too believe we don't need God? I am like a skeptic who eons ago got advice from a Roman High Priest derived from his "readings" of the entrails of a gutted calf. How can I, lacking the ability to read entrails or understand quantum theory, trust the Priest's explanations? Perhaps we should ask the Priest: "Are you required to provide an atheistic explanation for the origin of the universe and life? Can you ever entertain the alternative suggested by much of the evidence and the title of your book that the apparent design of the universe and of life may be real?" The questions are answered on pages 29-34. For Hawking, "Modern science" does not allow any intervention in the natural world by an intelligent cause. Only an atheistic answer may be given by the "modern scientist" to the ultimate question. Richard Lewontin, another "modern scientist," explains that this Dogma or commitment to "materialism is absolute, for we cannot allow a Divine Foot in the door." Oddly, Hawking asks if the universe "needs a creator," when he knows his Dogma doesn't permit it. This is weird, because the Dogma suppresses critical thinking and open-minded inquiry, the core value of true science. Why does he even write the book or engage in the inquiry if the answer is specified in advance? Imagine a coroner sent to the ascertain the cause of a death. He finds the deceased hanging by the neck from a tree, hands tied behind his back, and five tightly spaced arrows buried in his heart. An autopsy shows an arrow caused the death when it stopped the heart. The prosecutor looks at the coroner's report, which classifies the death as "accidental," and says: "This is absurd, the data shows a homicide." The coroner, responds: "Well the rules don't allow an intelligent cause, so the only ones left are natural or accidental. The death was not natural, so it must be accidental." I read on with growing skepticism. In Chapter 7 - "The Apparent Miracle," Hawking details significant evidence that the Universe and the properties of the matter, energy and forces that constrain it have been "fine-tuned" or designed for life. Life would not exist if any of the values of these physical features had been set differently by just a small amount. So, the data "suggests" a "miracle" accounts for life. The only way to show the miracle to be an illusion is to show it happened by chance. But a single universe doesn't provide enough chances. So to not "need" God, he needs more chances, which he artfully acquires by pulling 10500 additional "parallel" universes out of a quantum hat. But we can't observe any of these other universes, count them or know how they arose, if they did. There is an additional problem with this seemingly contrived explanation. It rests on the false assumption, explained on page 32, that once the laws of physics and chemistry are in place, they determine life, just as they determine "the orbits of the planets." This is not the case, as biochemists have known for fifty years that the laws of physics and chemistry do not determine the content of the messages in DNA that drive life. The sequences of the four genetic symbols that carry the messages of life per a "code" are arbitrary and not determined by law. Otherwise, DNA could not carry the functional information necessary to generate and control life. This misunderstanding undermines the no-God conclusion, for even if a quantum event can explain the laws of our Universe, those laws have not been shown adequate to explain the origin of life. Hawking's theology also uses an incorrect definition of "religion" when he seeks to exclude it from science. He admits the question his book addresses is "The Ultimate Question of Life." But, that is a religious as well as a scientific question. Legally and functionally, religion includes Atheism and other non-theistic beliefs, about ultimate questions - "matters of ultimate concern." Thus, his dogmatic no-God response to this religious question promotes the religion of Atheism, not an agnostic, open-minded science. So, whether or not intended, the effect of The Grand Design, is a misleading theology that promotes the religion of Atheism. It is not an objective discussion of the state of our scientific knowledge about origins. Atheists will love it, but they are not the only patrons and beneficiaries of science.
D**S
Simply magnificent
One of the best books I’ve ever read, and written by one of my heroes. Simply beautiful the way Stephen Hawking’s mind works
R**D
Science & Spirit meet in the middle
The Grand Design brings together all the various strands of quantum theory & makes some startling conclusions; specifically that our participation in the universe creates our own experience. So scientists and those of a more spiritual persuasion have finally met in the middle to agree on the contribution and role of consciousness in material creation - they just use different words. There are however two fuzzy areas in the book, the first is the absence of any discussion of the actual mechanism of how our participation creates our own experience and the specific force or energy that makes this happen. It's as if science cannot bring itself to make that final leap to admit that this force or energy must come from ourselves. The second issue relates to the book's conclusion that the universe could have started all by itself, without any first cause. This conclusion uses a convenient device to argue that before the big bang, time and space did not exist and therefore the idea of something pre-existing does not make any sense. Although fascinating in its contribution to our increasing understanding of the role of mankind in the great sheme of things, it is still very clear from this book that there is still a long way to go before science can finally claim to have found a theory of everything. Perhaps it might have to shake off some of its remaining prejudices against the contribution of the more spiritual traditions before it can do so.
H**S
Un libro bastante tecnico muy interesante
Un gran libro de vulgarizacion científica, que necesita un minimo de formación científica para poder entenderlo. Me gusto mucho y lo aconsejo.
S**L
Want to about universe?
Difficult to understand but ,if you were a physician title says what is inside the book
J**D
ouvreur d'horizons
la liberté de la pensée scientifique, bien que depuis qu'il l'a écrit les choses et connaissances ont évolué, le texte reste d'un intérêt majeur et il est écrit avec beaucoup de souci pédagogique, compréhensible pour le novice.
Trustpilot
3 weeks ago
1 month ago