Retractable Waterproof Eyeliner, Richly Pigmented Color and Creamy, Slip Twist Up Pencil Eye Liner, Smudge Proof Long Lasting Application, All Day Wear, No Sharpener Required, Black Brown

Nice, creamy formula goes on smoothly and stays put.

Great liner. Goes on smooth and last hours.

The color is amazing . Glides on smooth. Treat yourself to this quality liner.

I’ve used this eyeliner for literally YEARS; more than 10 at least, because it is the only brand that doesn’t hurt my extremely sensitive eyes. I’ve never had any problems with the longevity, the richness of color, or ease of application. Until now. Since I’ve used this for so long, it is easy for me to notice any change to the formula. The past 2 times I’ve ordered it, I’ve noticed very quickly that it is more creamier, and fully applies in seconds. I’ve always used it in my waterline with no problems at all. But lately, not only is it creamier, but the liner smears/goes away/fades very quickly in the corners of my eyes. I end up with black yuck in the corners of my eyes within a couple hours of applying. It literally fades down below my corners and it’s so annoying!! I set it, like always with setting powder, but it still happens. Also, my eyes are perfectly fine when I’m applying my makeup. But as soon as I use this eyeliner, they start to burn and they don’t stop until I wash everything off at night. I don’t know what they’ve changed but it’s definitely something. And I don’t like it at all. Now I have to search for another brand that doesn’t fade and doesn’t irritate and make my eyes burn. Ugh!!! Very disappointed.

This eyeliner is awesome. I have trouble with eyeliner staying on my eyes & not smearing. This is great. Doesn’t tug. Good price & good colors.

Pretty color, but does not seem so permanent.

I love this eyeliner. It glides on easily (I'm 60) and it stays on. I can put it on in the morning and have it on all day. I've purchased it many times and have purchased it for other people who are now just as excited about it as I am. Highly recommend!

Great eyeliner. Goes on smooth and easy and stays on.

لونه فاتح جدا و مش طري كفاية عشان اعيد بيه كتير و يبان

وحش ناشف جداا Not expected

Creamy smooth and long lasting. Very happy with purchase and would definitely buy again.

Je cherchais un crayon waterproof, hors il est absolument impossible de le passer, il ne tient pas, enfin je déconseille.

I like this because it’s retractable - much better than having to sharpen! Palladio is my go-to brand of eyeliner. I have this item in a few colours. I like the brand because it’s very easy to apply (glides on well) and stays on pretty well. I usually wear the olive version but time I tried the plum - very nice colour which isn’t as harsh as black. Definitely recommend.