365 by Whole Foods Market, Creamy Peanut Butter, Stir and Enjoy, 16 Ounce

OMG, this is literally the best tasing peanut-butter I've ever had in my life! The only listed ingredients are peanuts and salt, no sugar, no canola oil, no emulsifiers, no preservatives. It's so yummy I could cry! 🥰 *Also, what a price. I could have purchased 3 jars, for under $10, with delivery! 🤠 (it's a little 'runny,' but not 'separated.' frankly, the texture is 'perfect' for spreading. just be sure to hold the jar 'level' when you open it.)

OK GUYS LISTEN: dont even open the jar until its warm enough to shake it. If only the oil is moving around, it's too cold. A good majority, if not all of it should be able to move freely in the jar. But you want to shake it several minutes so its one consistency. You can pour it somewhat and not need a spoon. Thickness will increase the more you shake it. Less shaking = more runny initially then more solid feeling after the first half of the jar. This my favorite peanut butter ever. But you have you make sure the seal under the lid is %100, especially high altitudes, or the jar will have a chance to be rancid, the hotter and longer it's open, the worse chances it being good. This is mostly when having it shipped. If you use it within a week or so, you dont need to bother with refrigeration. If you get multiple jars, put the extras upside down to help mixing when you open a new one. Ideally in a warmer area of your home to facilitate mixing. Its the peanut oil that makes it taste good

This peanut butter was horrendous, it was so bad that it's almost funny! When I opened it, it came splashing out of the container all over my kitchen counters. It's about the consistency of chocolate milk. It's supposed to be creamy but it's not. While it isn't "chunky," it has very large pieces all throughout that can get caught on a strainer. The good note is that it's so watery, that it WILL go through a strainer and that's not normal for peanut butter. I bought this brand for preschool projects, not for a food item and it could not be used. The kids were making peanut butter pine cone bird feeders but the peanut butter is so thin that it won't even stock to the pinecones. The consistency and texture were so bad that I would NEVER eat this product...and I will never use it for a craft project again. Absolutely the worst I've ever encountered. (I did stir what was left after it came splashing out of the jar. I'm aware that oil can pool on the surface, but this looked exactly like it had been taken out of a blender.) If zero stars were an option, I would have chosen that lol!

Very oily, not just creamy but some crunchy peanut bits. Love that it's just peanut butter and salt though. It's really not thick at all, too best for peanut butter and jelly sandwiches but good for sauces.

This peanut butter needs stirring before use. The taste is great and not sweet. It’s a healthy peanut butter without additives. After stirring, the texture is runny and I use a spoon to spread.

I love this peanut butter. It may be a little salty but that's okay. It is very hard to stir but using a knife, as suggested, works well. I placed it in the refrigerator after stirring and it is still a little runny but very usable. It's nice to have something that tastes so good without all the additives etc. So much better for you and my dog loves it too. I would say that it is a little more grainy than your store bought Jif or other brands but I would expect that from all natural. I will definitely buy again.

Love this peanut butter! Perfect consistency! I also love the simple ingredients. Worth the buy!

I have never given a 2 star review before, but there is always a first time. Had bits of peanuts in creamy style. So oily even after stirring it was runny. Would not recommend or purchase again.